---
title: Why Active Managers Underperform in 2026 | Whitepaper from Burney
description: Idiosyncratic dispersion is at a 2008 high, yet most active managers still trail. Our 12-page paper explains why, and what the exceptions have in common.
image: https://burneyadvisorservices.com/hubfs/PDFs/white_papers/earning-alpha-preview.png
---

[![logo\_footer](https://burneyadvisorservices.com/hubfs/Theme/logo_footer.svg "logo_footer")](https://burneyadvisorservices.com?hsLang=en)

# Earning Alpha:

# Being Active Isn't Enough

Download our new white paper. Learn why a market built for stock picking still beat most active managers, and what separates the ones it didn’t.

[Download the White Paper ➝](https://burneyadvisorservices.com/earning-alpha-white-paper#download)

*\*For investment advisers and institutional investors only.*

![earning-alpha-preview](https://burneyadvisorservices.com/hs-fs/hubfs/PDFs/white_papers/earning-alpha-preview.png?width=1545&height=1999&name=earning-alpha-preview.png "earning-alpha-preview")

**THE PROBLEM**

## Your Clients Are in Active Funds. But Are They Getting Alpha?

The 2026 market looks unusually supportive for stock pickers. The macro forces that shaped the post-2020 cycle have faded, earnings have driven returns since the second quarter, and idiosyncratic dispersion among S&P 500 constituents sits at its highest level since 2008. Even inside the Magnificent Seven, performance is diverging sharply.

And many active managers are still behind.  
Reports from Morningstar and S&P Global show the majority trailing their benchmarks anyway. SPIVA puts 84.91% of large-cap growth funds behind the S&P 500 Growth year to date, and 95.44% behind over three years. The conditions that should favor stock selection are not translating into results.

This paper explains why that gap exists and what separates the managers it doesn’t apply to.

| "Taken together, these forces point to a theme-driven rather than a fundamentals-driven market, one in which active managers are not as well positioned as they appear." \- Earning Alpha: Being Active Isn't Enough |
| --- |

 

**WHAT'S INSIDE**

## What You'll Learn in 12 Pages

| ### 01 The Dispersion Issue Two conditions look strongly supportive. Idiosyncratic dispersion is at its highest since 2008, and single-stock volatility runs well above index volatility. The ingredients that are missing get less attention. Breadth remains weak by historical standards and pairwise correlation sits near historic lows, and S&P Dow Jones Indices argues active managers need both high dispersion and high correlation. This market delivers one, not both. | ### 02 Quality Factors Ran Backwards Return on equity and net profit margin have signaled sound operations for decades, and fundamental managers have favored both for just as long. Over the past year the relationship inverted. The lowest quintile on each measure delivered the strongest cumulative active return, leaving managers who held a disciplined quality approach on the wrong side of the market. |
| --- | --- |
| ### 03 What Concentration Costs Benchmark concentration is at a historical high and it’s worst in growth, where the 20 largest holdings account for roughly 69% of SPYG against 34% of SPYV. We model what a 5% position cap surrendered on NVIDIA and Apple alone in 2026. Roughly one percentage point of return, from two names. | ### 04 What the Managers Who Beat It Have in Common We analyzed all 467 active U.S. equity mutual funds and ETFs identified through Morningstar. Systematic managers outperformed discretionary peers by 3.3 percentage points year to date. Factor positioning, number of holdings, and a prior record of generating alpha separated the rest of the field. |

[Download the White Paper ➝](https://burneyadvisorservices.com/tax-aware-long-short-whitepaper/?hsLang=en#download)

**ABOUT THE RESEARCH**

## Burney Has Been Picking Stocks Since 1974.

Alex Shen authored this paper at Burney Advisor Services, a division of The Burney Company. Burney has been a registered investment adviser since 1974, with offices in Reston, Virginia and Nashville, Tennessee. Morningstar classifies the firm as a systematic manager.

The analysis covers all 467 active U.S. equity mutual funds and ETFs identified through Morningstar, grouped by strategy classification, equity style, market capitalization and fund size. Market data runs from 2000 through 2026 across the S&P Composite 1500 universe, with year-to-date figures through October 9, 2026. All assumptions are disclosed in the paper, and the full methodology is available on request from the authors. 

This paper was written to inform manager selection and client recommendations.

| ![FA100\_LOGO\_BADGES\_2026\_THUMBNAIL\_WHITE](https://burneyadvisorservices.com/hs-fs/hubfs/FA100_LOGO_BADGES_2026_THUMBNAIL_WHITE.png?width=141&height=95&name=FA100_LOGO_BADGES_2026_THUMBNAIL_WHITE.png) 8th Consecutive Year on the CNBC FA100 | ![2026Top1500](https://burneyadvisorservices.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Awards/2026Top1500.jpg?width=105&height=127&name=2026Top1500.jpg) Top 1500 Independent Advisors (Barron's 2014–2026) |
| --- | --- |

 

  **DOWNLOAD NOW**

## Get the White Paper

Complete the short form. You'll get the paper immediately, plus a follow-up email with a permanent download link.

| ✓ | Takes 30 seconds. Name, email, and a professional confirmation. |
| --- | --- |
| ✓ | Covers market dispersion and breadth, factor inversion, benchmark concentration, and what separates the managers still outperforming. |
| ✓ | All assumptions disclosed in the paper itself. |
| ✓ | Research you can use to make better decisions for your clients. |
| ✓ | Full methodology details available upon request from the authors |

 

![Primary - Bright Blue BG](https://burneyadvisorservices.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Logos/Primary%20-%20Bright%20Blue%20BG.png?width=200&height=61&name=Primary%20-%20Bright%20Blue%20BG.png "Primary - Bright Blue BG")

*Advisory services are offered through the Burney Company, an investment advisor registered with the U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission. SEC registration does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the Commission nor does it indicate that the advisor has attained a particular level of skill or ability*

*CNBC’s annual FA 100 ranking was published on 10/1/2025 for the year 2025.  The Burney Company did not pay CNBC any compensation for being considered for the list, however, Burney Company does pay a licensing fee to use the CNBC logo in marketing materials.  A link to the CNBC selection criteria can be found by going to https://www.cnbc.com/2025/10/01/financial-advisor-100-methodology-2025.html. The CNBC award was given to The Burney Company, which includes portfolio managers associated with Burney Wealth Management and nine other affiliated portfolio managers.*

*Barrons Top 1200 ranking was published on 3/10/2026 for the year 2026. The Burney Company did not pay Barrons any compensation for being considered for the list, however, Burney Company does pay an annual fee for access to its “Digital Marketing Package” that provides Burney with an upgraded online profile. A link to Barrons selection criteria can be found by going to https://www.barrons.com. The Barrons award was presented to Burney President Lowell Pratt.*

 

*Advisory services are offered through the Burney Company, an investment advisor registered with the U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission. SEC registration does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the Commission nor does it indicate that the advisor has attained a particular level of skill or ability*

*CNBC’s annual FA 100 ranking was published on 10/1/2025 for the year 2025.  The Burney Company did not pay CNBC any compensation for consideration for the list; however, it does pay a licensing fee to use the CNBC logo in marketing materials.  A link to the CNBC selection criteria can be found by going to https://www.cnbc.com/2025/10/01/financial-advisor-100-methodology-2025.html. The CNBC award was given to The Burney Company, which includes portfolio managers associated with Burney Wealth Management, as well as nine other affiliated portfolio managers.*

*Barron's Top 1200 ranking was published on 3/10/2026 for the year 2026. The Burney Company did not pay Barrons any compensation for being considered for the list; however, Burney Company does pay an annual fee for access to its “Digital Marketing Package” that provides Burney with an upgraded online profile. A link to Barron's selection criteria is available at https://www.barrons.com. The Barron's award was presented to Burney President Lowell Pratt.*

*HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE — IMPORTANT NOTICE  
The analyses, charts, and portfolio projections contained in the White Paper are based entirely on hypothetical simulations and modeled outcomes. They do not represent the actual performance of any investment product, account, fund, or strategy managed by The Burney Company or any affiliated entity.  No actual client assets were managed using this strategy during the periods depicted. Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain inherent limitations.   No representation is being made that any account will, or is likely to, achieve profits or losses similar to those shown.* 

*130/30 Disclosures:  
We execute this strategy at two custodian firms: Interactive Brokers and Schwab.  Both custodians offer competitive margin rates vs other custodians.  Clients seeking to utilize this strategy will need to sign a margin agreement with the custodian firm. The strategy can only be executed in taxable accounts with a minimum investment of $250k.  
The primary risks associated with this strategy include the following:*

- Unlimited risk of loss from short selling. Unlike long positions, where losses are limited to the initial investment, the price of a stock sold short can rise indefinitely, potentially causing rapid and unlimited losses. The Burney Company employs various measures to reduce this risk, but losses can still occur.
- Leverage and margin risk. Long-short strategies use margin to boost exposure, increasing both potential gains and losses. A decline in stock value can trigger margin calls.
- Tracking error and portfolio risk. There is potential for tracking error due to the performance of our stock selection model. Success depends on the portfolio manager’s ability to choose both winning longs and losing shorts. Poor timing or incorrect analysis can lead to losses on either side. Additionally, in volatile market conditions, the assumed hedge between long and short positions may break down, leaving the portfolio vulnerable to broad market downturns.
- Costs and tax implications. This portfolio incurs additional expenses, including margin charges, as detailed in the margin agreement. Additionally, closing out positions can lead to significant short-term capital gains tax liabilities that may not be fully offset.
- Liquidity risks.  Some short positions may become difficult to borrow or cover, particularly in volatile markets, making unwinding difficult.

*The strategy is intended for sophisticated investors with aggressive or moderately aggressive risk tolerances who understand its complexity and the potential for unlimited losses associated with short selling.  Past performance is not indicative of future results.  All investments involve risk, including loss of principal.*